8 Pancakes in NYC So Good, You’ll Order Seconds (#5 Is Life-Changing)

Written By Anthony Tam

When it comes to brunch in New York City, pancakes are an undeniable staple. Whether you're a local or a visitor, the city offers many options to satisfy your pancake cravings. From classic stacks to innovative creations, New York City has some of the best breakfast places in the country. When it comes to pancakes, Silver Star Restaurant in Lenox Hill is a must-visit. This family-owned Greek diner has been serving tasty pancakes since 1965. They offer everything from classic buttermilk to rich Nutella-stacked options. If you are looking for "the best pancakes near me," check out Silver Star. They have delicious pancakes that every pancake lover will enjoy. Everyone deserves the perfect stack!

Silver Star Restaurant’s Pancake Menu: A NYC Breakfast Icon

Pancakes with bacon, ham or sausage

1. Pancakes with Bacon, Ham or Sausage

If you enjoy a mix of sweet and savory, try Silver Star’s pancakes. They come with crispy bacon, juicy ham, or tasty sausage. The salty meat pairs perfectly with fluffy buttermilk pancakes and a drizzle of maple syrup.

Best for: Breakfast traditionalists who love a hearty meal.

Pancakes topped with fresh strawberries and blueberries.

2. Pancakes with Fresh Strawberries & Blueberries

These pancakes are light and fruity. They are full of flavor and have fresh strawberries and blueberries. These fruits add natural sweetness to each bite. A dollop of whipped cream takes it to the next level.

Best for: A refreshing, slightly healthier pancake fix.

Oreo pancakes is every one's favorite

3. OREO Pancakes

A cookie lover’s paradise, these pancakes are stuffed with crushed OREO pieces and topped with extra cookie crumbs. Drizzled with chocolate syrup, they’re a decadent breakfast (or dessert!) treat.

Best for: Kids and anyone with a serious sweet tooth.

Banana pancakes is sweet and moist.

4. Banana Pancakes

Creamy, caramelized bananas are mixed into the batter and placed on top. This makes the pancakes sweet and very moist. A sprinkle of cinnamon adds warmth to every bite.

Best for: Fans of classic, comforting flavors.

Nutella pancakes with cut banana.

5. Nutella Pancakes

If you love Nutella, this stack is for you. Silver Star’s Nutella pancakes are rich and chocolatey. They are also gooey, with lots of hazelnuts spread between each layer.

Best for: A truly indulgent breakfast experience.

Healthy wheat pancakes topped with honey.

6. Wheat Pancakes

If you want a healthier option, try Silver Star’s whole-wheat pancakes. They are just as fluffy as the classic ones, but they have more fiber and a nutty taste. Top them with honey or fresh fruit for a guilt-free treat.

Best for: Health-conscious diners who still want delicious pancakes.

Fluffy lemon ricotta pancakes, perfect for brunch lovers.

7. Lemon Ricotta Pancakes

These light, fluffy, and slightly tangy pancakes are made with creamy ricotta cheese and fresh lemon zest. They’re a sophisticated take on traditional pancakes, perfect for brunch lovers.

Best for: Foodies looking for a gourmet pancake experience.

Apple cinnamon pancakes topped with butter and maple syrup.

8. Apple Cinnamon Pancakes

Warm, spiced, and loaded with tender apple chunks, these pancakes taste like autumn in every bite. A dusting of cinnamon sugar and a side of whipped cream makes them extra cozy.

Best for: A comforting, seasonal breakfast.

Why Pancake Lovers Flock to Silver Star?

The Silver Star Restaurant has garnered a loyal following, and for good reason. Its pancakes are not just a meal but an experience. The combination of a cozy atmosphere and delectable food makes it a beloved spot in NYC's vibrant culinary landscape. Whether you're a local or a tourist, a visit to Silver Star will leave you craving for more.

In a city filled with dining options, finding the perfect pancake can be a daunting task. However, Silver Star Restaurant's legendary stacks make it easy. So, if you're on the hunt for the best pancakes NYC has to offer, look no further than Silver Star. Your taste buds will thank you.

Have you tried the pancakes at Silver Star Restaurant? Share your experience with us in the comments below!

Tips for the Ultimate Pancake Feast

To make the most of your visit to Silver Star Restaurant, consider these tips:

  1. Timing is Everything: Visit during off-peak hours to avoid long waits and enjoy a more relaxed dining experience.

  2. Check the Specials: Look for the daily specials. They often have unique pancake creations not found on the regular menu.

  3. Bring Friends: Pancakes are best enjoyed with company. Share different stacks to sample a variety of flavors.

Silver Star Restaurant: NYC’s Hidden Pancake Gem

This retro diner is a dream for pancake lovers. It serves fluffy stacks with both classic and new flavors. Here’s what sets their pancakes apart and makes them memorable:

Must-Try Pancakes at Silver Star:

  1. OREO Pancakes – Crushed cookies inside the batter, topped with whipped cream.

  2. Nutella Pancakes – Hazelnut chocolate spread melted between layers.

  3. Bacon Pancakes – Savory-sweet perfection with crispy bacon bits.

  4. Lemon Ricotta Pancakes – Light, fluffy, and zesty.

  5. Banana Pancakes – Caramelized bananas in every bite (life-changing!).

  6. Strawberry & Blueberry Pancakes – Bursting with fresh fruit.

  7. Apple Cinnamon Pancakes – Warm, spiced, and cozy.

  8. Wheat Pancakes – A healthier (but still delicious) option.

The 6 Other Best Pancake Spots in NYC

1. Clinton Street Baking Co. (Lower East Side)

Best Blueberry Pancakes
Their fluffy stacks + warm maple butter sauce are worth the wait (and yes, there will be a line).

2. Sunday in Brooklyn (Williamsburg)

Best Gourmet Pancakes
Try their malted pancakes with honeycomb butter—a brunch game-changer.

3. Tom’s Restaurant (Prospect Heights)

Best Classic Diner Pancakes
A Seinfeld-famous spot with perfect buttermilk stacks and retro vibes.

4. The Butcher’s Daughter (Nolita/Williamsburg)

Best Vegan Pancakes
Fluffy almond-flour pancakes with seasonal fruit compote.

5. Bubby’s (Tribeca/High Line)

Best Farm-to-Table Pancakes
Organic buttermilk pancakes with local maple syrup.

6. IHOP (Multiple Locations)

Best Budget-Friendly Pancakes
Endless options, including the viral Cinnabon stack.

Anthony Tam

A longtime New Yorker with a diverse global perspective, Anthony Tam combines expertise in the NYC real estate market with a professional communications background and unparalleled analytic skills. Experienced in residential sales, rentals and commercial real estate throughout NYC, Anthony has a particular expertise in Battery Park City, the Financial District and the West Village. Adept at forming quick connections with clients, he is a creative, action-oriented thinker who genuinely loves helping people discover New York and fulfill their real estate goals.

Prior to venturing into real estate, Anthony was a brand manager specializing in digital advertising and marketing. He is extremely well versed in the latest technology, a skill set that allows him to analyze all opportunities on behalf of his buyers and craft innovative marketing plans for each of his sellers. He always listens closely to each client's needs and wants, then takes a strategic, story-centric approach that blends analytic and statistical research with his broad knowledge of local properties and neighborhoods. Above all, he has a knack for making the process fun and easy for everyone involved.

Born in Malaysia, Anthony is a graduate of Parsons The New School for Design with a BFA in Communication Design, and has made New York City his home for over a decade. Fluent in Mandarin and Cantonese, his diverse background and experiences enhance his ability to service a broad range of clients. When not out exploring New York City neighborhoods, he can often be found swimming, working out, or taking in a movie. 

http://www.anthonytam.com
Next

Silver Star’s breakfast brunch lunch and diner